Recently, the East Oregonian published an editorial about the long-overdue plan revisions for the national forests of the Blue Mountains. This editorial included a statement that challenged the need to close any roads on the national forests, suggesting that closing a road meant “closing the forests to logging, firefighting, hikers, hunters, and other users.”

I speak on behalf of closed roads. Closing a road to motorized vehicle traffic does not close the forest. Hikers, hunters, anglers, mushroom and huckleberry pickers, Christmas tree cutters — we all use closed roads. As good local research shows, and hunters know, closed roads provide good habitat for elk. Elk avoid roads that are open to motor vehicles.

Closing a road does not mean the road cannot be used for logging or firefighting. During my Forest Service career, it was not at all unusual to open a closed road to help fight a fire. Sometimes it means simply unlocking a gate, and sometimes it takes a dozer to remove earthen barriers, but closed roads are usually still available for fire fighting.

Just like any asset, a road system must be maintained. The money appropriated to national forests to maintain roads is inadequate for maintaining the road system that was developed when the forests sold more (and more valuable) timber. Closing a road to motor vehicles holds the road in better condition until the day that it is needed again, and this seems to me to be a prudent approach.

We can, and should, have an open and honest public dialogue about what we want from our national forests, including the road system. Provocative misstatements, like suggesting that closing roads means “locking up” or closing the forests to all sorts of uses, does not help this dialogue.

William C. (Bill) Aney


Recommended for you

(1) comment

Irene Gilbert

This guy must be kidding. Closing roads to motorized vehicles removes access to the bulk of the forest users. It sounds good that people can just climb over the barriers and stroll along the areas where roads have been blocked. My experience has been that in roughly 5 years the trees, blackberries and invasive weeds take over the area where the road existed. I am a 70 year old woman. There is no way I can go mushrooming, berry picking or do the things I normally do with my grandchildren, ages 5 through 14 in areas where the road has been blocked. Carrying lunches, water, whatever we gather, and carrying the young children when they become tired (which may not take very long) makes the outing torture for everyone. Every year I find it increasingly difficult to access the areas I used to go without a thought. My better half has rumatoid arthritis, and it is impossible for him to hike up hills for even short distances without excruciating pain. I am happy for this individual that he continues to be able to access the forests absent the assistance of a vehicle. I wish that the rest of us were equally blessed.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.